There's no fixed amount. The government guidance doesn't give a percentage, so don't trust anyone who quotes one as a rule [1][2]. The Department for Transport says Category S cars are often slightly cheaper to buy than similar cars of the same age and mileage [2]. It says nothing about Cat N prices. The honest answer is that you measure the gap yourself, for the exact car, by comparing real listings.
That sounds like more work than a rule of thumb. It is. It's also the only number that will hold up when you come to sell.
What the categories actually mean
Before you price the gap, be clear what the label tells a buyer. Your insurer decides whether to write the car off, and what happens next depends on which category the car is in [1]. GOV.UK lists four:
| Category | What GOV.UK says | Can it go back on the road? |
|---|---|---|
| A | Can't be repaired. The whole vehicle has to be crushed. | No |
| B | Can't be repaired. The body shell has to be crushed, but other parts can be salvaged. | No |
| S | Can be repaired after structural damage. | Yes, once roadworthy |
| N | Can be repaired after non-structural damage. | Yes, once roadworthy |
So only S and N cars can be repaired and used again [1]. The rest of this guide is about those two.
How much less is a Cat N car worth?
There's no official answer. The Department for Transport's guide says a repaired written-off car can often be good value, and that Category S cars are often slightly cheaper to buy than similar cars of the same age and mileage [2]. That's as far as the official guidance goes. It says nothing about Cat N prices, and it gives no number for Cat N or Cat S. So for a Cat N, check what real Cat N examples of the same car have sold for.
So treat any percentage you read online as someone's opinion. It might be right for the car they looked at. It won't be right for every car.
How to work out a Cat S car valuation yourself
Here's the method. It takes about half an hour per car.
- Find the clean price. Search for the same make, model, engine, trim, year and similar mileage, with no write-off history. Note the asking prices of several. Look at private and trade adverts separately, because they price differently.
- Find the Cat N or Cat S price. Now search for the same car with the same category. You may need to widen the year or mileage a bit. Note those asking prices too.
- Compare like with like. Put the two sets side by side. Ignore the odd one that's priced far too high or too low. The gap between the middle of each set is your working figure for that model.
- Check what actually sold, not just what's listed. Asking prices are hopes. If a car has been listed for weeks, it's probably priced too high. Cars that vanish quickly tell you more about what buyers will really pay.
- Write it down. Keep a note of the listings you used. When you sell, you'll want to show you priced fairly.
If you can't find enough Cat N or Cat S examples of that model, that's a signal in itself. It may mean a small buyer pool, which usually means a longer wait to sell.
What moves the gap
The gap isn't the same for every car. These are the things that move it.
- Category. S means the structure was damaged; N means it wasn't [1]. Expect buyers to be warier of an S than an N of the same car.
- Type of damage. A light front-end knock is a different story from a flood or a fire. Buyers will ask what happened, and the answer changes the price.
- Repair quality. The DfT guide tells buyers to get the car inspected by an engineer who will look for structural damage, and to ask who handled the car between the write-off and the repair [2]. A car with a clear repair record, photos and receipts is easier to sell than one with none.
- Make and model. Some cars are bought by people who mainly care about price and running costs. Others are bought partly for the badge and the clean history. The second kind usually takes a bigger hit.
- Buyer pool. Expect some private buyers to rule out a written-off car altogether. Fewer interested buyers means you'll need to price lower or wait longer.
- Insurance. The DfT guide warns that insuring a written-off car can cost more, and that not all insurers will automatically cover one [2]. Buyers who get a high quote, or a refusal, walk away. That pushes the price down.
How much is a Cat S car worth to a flipper?
To you, a Cat S or Cat N car is worth what you can sell it for once it's repaired, minus everything it costs you to get there. The market gap above is what turns the clean price into a realistic resale estimate.
Here's a made-up example to show the arithmetic. None of these figures are real market data.
Example only. A hatchback comes up at Brindle Auctions as an unrepaired Cat N. Clean cars of the same model, year and mileage are listed at around £8,000. Repaired Cat N examples of the same car are listed at around £6,800. So your working gap for this model is about £1,200, and your resale estimate is £6,800, not £8,000.
That £6,800 is the number you take into your sums. From it you subtract the repair, the auction fees, transport, any paperwork and selling costs, and the margin you want. What's left is the most you should bid.
Two habits help:
- Price the car you'll actually sell. If you're repairing a Cat S to sell privately, compare it with private Cat S adverts, not with dealer prices for clean cars.
- Be pessimistic. If the gap you found is somewhere between two figures, use the bigger one. You can always be pleasantly surprised.
Don't hide the category to close the gap
You might be tempted to skip mentioning the category to get a clean-car price. Don't. The DfT guide tells buyers to tell their insurer about any previous write-off, because an insurer can reject a claim for non-disclosure [2]. So your buyer needs to know, and a buyer who finds out later will come back to you. Price the car as what it is.
Check it before you bid
Once you've got your resale estimate, you can check a lot's Max Bid in Karflipper before you bid. It takes your resale figure and the costs above and tells you the most you can pay and still make your margin.
Sources
- 1. GOV.UK: Scrapped and written-off vehicles – Insurance write-offs
- 2. Department for Transport: Buying repaired 'written off' vehicles – a consumer guide