Cat S is the more serious label. A Cat S car was written off after structural damage, while a Cat N car was written off after non-structural damage [1]. Both can be repaired and used again once they're back to a roadworthy condition [1], so "worse" is about the kind of damage, not whether the car is finished.
That's the label. The car in front of you is a different question. A neat Cat S repair can be a better buy than a bodged Cat N. So use the category to decide how hard to look, not as the whole answer.
What is the difference between Cat S and Cat N cars?
When an insurer writes a car off, it puts it in a category. GOV.UK lists four [1]:
- A: can't be repaired. The whole vehicle has to be crushed.
- B: can't be repaired. The body shell has to be crushed, but other parts can be salvaged.
- S: can be repaired following structural damage.
- N: can be repaired following non-structural damage.
S and N are the two you'll see for sale as repairable salvage. The Department for Transport calls these a "constructive loss": the car could be repaired, but the repair would cost more than the car was worth [2]. A and B are an "actual loss" and won't be re-registered by DVLA [2].
So a Cat N write-off isn't a minor-damage badge. It just means the insurer judged the repair wasn't worth paying for, and the damage wasn't to the structure.
Cat N vs Cat S side by side
| Cat N | Cat S | |
|---|---|---|
| Type of damage | Non-structural [1] | Structural [1] |
| Can it go back on the road? | Yes, once repaired to a roadworthy condition [1] | Yes, once repaired to a roadworthy condition [1] |
| Log book (V5C) when the owner keeps it | Owner can keep the log book [1] | Full log book goes to the insurer; owner applies for a free duplicate on form V62 and DVLA records the category in it [1] |
| Insurance | Can cost more, and not every insurer covers written-off cars [2] | Same rule applies [2] |
| Price to buy repaired | No official figure | Often slightly cheaper than similar age and mileage cars [2] |
| What to look hardest at | Everything the damage touched, plus any shortcuts in the repair | The structure, and whether it's been put back properly |
That log book row matters if you flip. If the owner keeps a Cat S car, DVLA records the category in the V5C [1]. Whoever buys from you will see it.
What is worse, Cat N or Cat S?
On paper, Cat S, because the damage reached the car's structure [1]. That's the part you most need put back right.
In practice, judge the car, not the letter. The DfT guide tells buyers to check the car has been properly repaired and is roadworthy, ask who handled it between the write-off and the repair, and get an independent expert or engineer to look for structural damage [2]. It also warns that an inspection can turn up faults that have nothing to do with the original crash [2]. That applies to both categories.
If you're buying unrepaired salvage to fix and sell, the same logic runs the other way. A Cat S car means you're taking on a structural repair, and it needs to be done properly. Cat N rules out structural damage, but "non-structural" doesn't tell you how much damage there is. Price the actual job from the photos and the inspection, not from the letter.
Cat N vs Cat S insurance
There's no official rule that sets Cat S insurance higher than Cat N. What the DfT guide does say applies to both:
- Insuring a written-off car can cost more, and not all insurers will automatically cover one [2].
- Get a quote before you buy, so a cheap price isn't wiped out by a much higher premium [2].
- Tell your insurer the car has been a total loss. If you don't, they can reject a claim on the grounds of non-disclosure [2].
If you're flipping, your buyer faces the same questions. Expect them to ask, and expect some to walk away once they've rung their insurer. That's worth building into the price you'll get.
Cat N vs Cat S vs Cat D
You'll still see Cat C and Cat D in old adverts and on older cars. They aren't among the four categories GOV.UK lists today [1]. The current insurers' code of practice came into effect in October 2017 and replaced an earlier version [2]. Before that, the government described repairable write-offs as "salvage category C or D": cars that could be repaired, but where the repair would cost more than the replacement value [3]. For more on the old letters, see Cat A, B, C and D explained.
Don't try to translate an old letter into a new one and stop there. Treat a Cat C or Cat D car exactly as you would an S or N: find out what was damaged, who repaired it, and get it inspected [2].
The quick version
- Cat S: structural damage. Cat N: non-structural damage [1].
- Both can go back on the road once roadworthy [1].
- If the owner keeps a Cat S car, DVLA records the category in the log book [1].
- Insurance for either can cost more. Get a quote before you buy and always declare it [2].
- The repair matters more than the letter. Get an independent inspection [2].
Before you bid on a Cat N or Cat S lot, run it through Karflipper. It works out a Max Bid from the repair, the fees and what the car should sell for, so the category is priced in before you raise your hand.
Sources
- 1. GOV.UK, Insurance write-offs
- 2. Department for Transport, Buying repaired 'written off' vehicles: a consumer guide
- 3. GOV.UK news story, Scrapping unnecessary checks will save honest motorists around £10 million a year (26 October 2015)