How to work out your Max Bid on a damaged car

Fact-checked 20 November 2026 · 1 source

In short

Start from the resale price, take off repairs, fees, transport, prep, a contingency and your margin. What's left is the most you should bid.

The most you should bid at a car auction is what's left after you take every cost, and the profit you need, off what the car will sell for once it's fixed. That figure is your Max Bid. Work it out before the auction starts, write it down, and don't go a pound over.

The maths is easy. The hard part is being honest about each line.

Start from the Resale Value, not the hammer price

Everything works backwards from what the car will sell for once it's repaired. That's your Resale Value.

  • Look at real cars, not hopes. Find the same make, model, year, engine and mileage, for sale near you. Ignore the shiniest ones.
  • Allow for the category. A Cat N or Cat S car can go back on the road once it's repaired to a roadworthy condition [1], but expect buyers to compare it with cars that have no history. Compare against other cars with the same category if you can find them.
  • Have a floor. Know what the trade would pay if it doesn't sell retail. If the sum only works at the top of the market, it doesn't work.

Take off every cost

Go through these one at a time. A line you skip is a line that comes out of your profit later.

  • Repairs. Parts and labour to make it sellable and road-legal. Price it panel by panel, light by light. Decide whether you're pricing new, aftermarket or used parts, and stick with it.
  • Auction fees and VAT. Expect buyer's fees on top of the hammer price. Check the auction's own fee table for the price band you're bidding in, and whether VAT is added to the fees.
  • Storage. Check whether the yard charges for storage and from when. Plan when you'll collect.
  • Transport. Getting it from the yard to your base. A non-runner needs a recovery truck or trailer, not a lift from a mate.
  • Paperwork and checks. A history check, an MOT, and anything else the car needs to be sold properly.
  • Prep and selling. Valet, photos, advert fees, maybe a set of tyres.
  • Contingency. Damaged cars hide things. A bent bracket behind the bumper, a sensor that won't talk to the car. Put a sum aside for what you can't see in the photos.

Then take off your margin

Your margin is the profit you need to make the job worth doing. Decide it before you bid, not while the clock is running.

Some flippers set it as a fixed sum. Others set it as a percentage of what the car costs them to buy. Either works. The point is that it's a cost like any other, so it comes off before you get to the bid. If you leave it until last, you'll talk yourself out of it.

A worked example (made-up numbers)

Here's how one car might look. Every figure below is invented for illustration. It isn't a real car, a real price or a real fee table. Brindle Auctions is a made-up auction house.

The car: a 2019 hatchback, Cat N, front-end damage, listed at Brindle Auctions.

Line Amount (made up) What's left
Resale Value once repaired £6,000 £6,000
Repairs: parts (bonnet, bumper, headlamp) − £700 £5,300
Repairs: labour and paint − £500 £4,800
Transport from the yard − £150 £4,650
Paperwork and checks − £100 £4,550
Prep and selling − £150 £4,400
Contingency − £300 £4,100
Your margin − £800 £3,300
Brindle Auctions fees + VAT (made-up flat fee for this price band) − £360 £2,940
Max Bid £2,940

So in this example, £2,940 is the highest hammer price where the deal still pays you £800. Bid £3,100 and you haven't lost money yet, but you've eaten into your margin. Bid £3,500 and you've given most of it away.

Two things to watch in the sum

Fees can move with the price. If the auction's fees step up in bands and your Max Bid lands near the edge of a band, check the fee in the band above too, then work it out again.

A percentage margin goes round in a circle. If your margin is a percentage of the buying cost, it depends on the bid, which depends on the margin. You can fix it by trying a bid, working out the margin, and adjusting until the numbers match. A spreadsheet or a calculator does this in seconds.

Check the bid against the room

At the auction, compare the current bid with your Max Bid, not with what the last car went for.

  • Current bid well under your Max Bid: there's room. Bid in steady steps.
  • Getting close: slow down. Remember the fee band.
  • Over your Max Bid: stop. Someone else has either worked out the car differently or hasn't worked it out at all. Either way, it isn't your car.

The car you don't buy costs you nothing. The car you overpay for costs you the whole margin, and sometimes more.

Things that change the sum

Run the numbers again if any of these turn up:

  • Damage you didn't spot in the photos: airbag lights, cracked mounts, wet carpets.
  • A non-runner when you'd assumed it drove.
  • A longer wait to sell than usual. Every week it sits there, it costs you something.
  • The category being different from what you expected.

Get the Max Bid worked out for you

Karflipper builds this waterfall for each lot: your Resale Value, repairs line by line, transport, prep and selling, auction fees and VAT, and your margin, with a Max Bid at the bottom. It also shows where each figure came from, so you can check it before you bid.

Sources

Every fact in this guide was checked against the sources listed, on 20 November 2026. Rules change, so follow the source links for the current position.