A Cat N or Cat S car can be worth buying, but only if the repair is sound and the price leaves room for the extra costs. The Department for Transport says there's nothing wrong with buying a written-off car that's been returned to a good condition, and that it can be good value [2]. The catch is that insurance can cost more, and you need to check the repair properly before you hand over money [2].
Whether it's worth it depends on why you're buying. Keeping a car and flipping one are different sums, so this guide takes them in turn.
Should I buy a Cat N repaired car to keep?
A Cat N car was written off after non-structural damage and can go back on the road once it's repaired to a roadworthy condition [1]. If you're buying one to drive, the questions are simple:
- Is the repair good? Check it's been properly repaired and is roadworthy [2].
- What will insurance cost? Get a quote before you buy. A cheap car isn't cheap if the premium eats the saving [2].
- What will it be worth when you sell? There's no official figure for how much a category knocks off. Look at what similar written-off cars are actually selling for, not what they're listed at.
If those three add up, it can be a sensible buy. If you can't get a quote you're happy with, walk away.
Should I buy a Cat S car? Is Cat S safe to buy?
A Cat S car was written off after structural damage [1]. It can also go back on the road once it's repaired to a roadworthy condition [1]. "Safe" depends entirely on that repair.
The DfT guide is blunt about what to do [2]:
- Get a report from an independent expert, or have an engineer inspect the car for structural damage.
- Ask who handled the car between the write-off and the repair.
- Remember an inspection may also find faults unrelated to the original crash.
It also says Cat S cars are often slightly cheaper than similar age and mileage cars, and if the price looks too good to be true, beware [2].
If the seller won't let you have it inspected, that tells you something.
What to check before you buy
These apply to Cat N and Cat S alike, from the DfT guide [2]:
| Check | Why |
|---|---|
| Private history check | Shows if the car's been stolen, has outstanding finance, has a mileage discrepancy or was written off |
| VIN on the car matches the V5C | Make sure the car is the one on the paperwork |
| V5C details match DVLA records | Use the DVLA vehicle enquiry service |
| MOT history (cars over 3 years old) | Free on GOV.UK |
| Full service history | Shows what maintenance has been done |
| Safety recalls | Check on GOV.UK |
| Independent inspection | Finds structural damage and hidden faults |
For Cat S, also expect the category in the log book. When an owner keeps a Cat S car, DVLA records the category in the V5C [1].
After you buy, tell your insurer the car has been a total loss. If you don't, they can reject a claim for non-disclosure [2]. You also need to tax the car before you drive it, or declare it off the road with a SORN. The tax doesn't transfer to you with the car [4].
Is it worth buying a Cat N or Cat S car to flip?
This is a different sum. You're not paying for a car to live with. You're paying for a margin.
Work it out before you bid, in this order:
- What it'll sell for once repaired. Use real sold prices for the same model, age, mileage and category. The category goes with the car, so price it in.
- Take off the repair. Parts, paint, labour, and anything the inspection or photos suggest might be hiding.
- Take off the fees. Buyer's fees, transport, MOT, valeting, advertising.
- Take off a buffer. Something always turns up.
- What's left is the most you can pay. If the hammer goes above it, let it go.
Illustration only: a Cat N hatchback at Brindle Auctions looks cheap against a clean one. But if your realistic sold price, minus the repair, fees and buffer, comes out below the current bid, it isn't cheap. It's a loss with a nice photo.
Two things are worth knowing about selling on.
First, your buyer faces the same insurance questions you did [2]. Some will ring their insurer and change their mind. Allow for slower sales.
Second, if you sell as a trader to a consumer, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 applies [3]. Goods have to be of satisfactory quality, and safety is one of the things that counts [3]. Goods sold by description have to match it [3]. A fault that was specifically pointed out to the buyer before the sale isn't covered by the satisfactory quality term [3]. That's one good reason to tell buyers the category in writing. The Act itself has the detail.
Cat N car for sale: reading the advert
When you see a Cat N or Cat S car for sale, read the advert as a starting point, not a promise. Then run the checks in the table above [2]. Ask:
- Who repaired it, and is there a record of what was done?
- Has it been inspected since the repair?
- Does the V5C match the car and DVLA's records [2]?
A good seller will have answers. A seller who goes vague is doing you a favour by warning you early.
The short answer
- Repaired Cat N and Cat S cars can be good value, according to the DfT [2].
- Check the repair, get an independent inspection, and get an insurance quote first [2].
- Declare the write-off to your insurer [2].
- To flip, work back from a real sold price, and don't bid past your number.
Before you bid on a Cat N or Cat S lot, check its Max Bid in Karflipper. It does the sum above for you, so you know your walk-away price before the bidding starts.
Sources
- 1. GOV.UK, Insurance write-offs
- 2. Department for Transport, Buying repaired 'written off' vehicles: a consumer guide
- 3. Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1, Chapter 2
- 4. GOV.UK, Tell DVLA you've sold, transferred or bought a vehicle